Joe Reilly, a two sport athlete who played football and ran track at Georgetown, was selected as head coach for both sports in 1904.

Reilly attended the Georgetown dental school as a coach, earning his DDS degree and staying at the University through the 1907 season. Following the 1907 season, Reilly announced he was retiring from coaching altogether, but later accepted a one year deal at Boston College for the 1908 season.

The whereabouts of Reilly after Georgetown are unknown, although a 1943 article listed him as the retired director of the Kansas City Athletic Club.

Year	Record	Pct.	Home	Away
1904	7-1	0.875	5-0	2-1
1905	2-7	0.222	2-5	0-2
1906	6-1	0.857	5-1	1-0
1907	2-4-1	0.357	2-2-1	0-2
Totals	17-13-1	0.513	14-8-1	3-5